UPDATE 03/12/2020: The SAPCC Board voted to respect the decision of the City Council and not to pursue any further action in regards to the 2495 Kasota site plan.
UPDATE 03/11/2020: Months of work led to a disappointing end at City Council when, after the decision was continued an additional week, Ward 4 Councilmember Mitra Jalali Nelson moved to deny the appeal brought forth by SAPCC. The City Council voted 6-1 against the appeal.
Watch the Public Hearing
March 4, 2020: 2495 Kasota topic at the public hearing starts at: 49:27 (our presentation starts almost immediately afterward)
March 11, 2020: 2495 Kasota topic at the public hearing starts at: 08:22
UPDATE 03/05/2020: At the Public Hearing on March 4th, supporters filled the seats of the City Council Chambers to hear arguments for the proposed site development at 2495 Kasota Ave. Board and Environment Committee Members from SAPCC presented their arguments, but were cut short before finishing. Community members were not invited to speak before the Public Hearing portion was closed, but those in attendance stood and applauded when Councilmember Dai Thao (Ward 1) asked who had been doing the maintenance and cleaning up of illegal dumping.
Councilmember Mitra Jalai (Ward 4) questioned the basis for the appeal and was hesitant to overturn decisions made by other agencies that do environmental assessments. She asked for clarification in understanding the permitted use under Zoning, and City’s Planning Goals vs. relevant land use laws.
Councilmember Jane Prince (Ward 7) saw basis for the appeal, but encouraged Rohn Industries and SAPCC to try to find a way to work things out.
The public hearing was closed, but President Amy Brendmoen (Ward 5) asked that those who did not get a chance to speak reach out and for the SAPCC presentation be sent to the Councilmembers.
Contact City Council via Email Please note: your email will become part of the public record.
UPDATE 02/13/2020: The public hearing for the appeal is now scheduled for March 4, 2020 at 5:30 p.m. before the City Council. SAPCC is requesting neighbors pledge to attend via Facebook.
UPDATE 01/15/2020: The City of Saint Paul has completed review of the petition for EAW, and has concluded that an EAW is not needed. Read documentation of the City’s findings and basis for decision.
Update 12/19/19: The EQB has reviewed the request for an extension for the decision on the need for an Environmental Assessment Worksheet (EAW) on the Rohn Industries Trailer Storage Petition. The request is respectfully granted in accordance with Minnesota Rules 4410.1100, Subpart 7. The new deadline for the City’s decision is Thursday, January 16th, 2020.
Update 12/3/19: SAPCC filed a Citizen’s Petition with the Environment Quality Board for an Environmental Assessment Worksheet for the Rohn Industries Trailer Storage project. The EQB has deemed the petition complete, and the City has decided to POSTPONE the public hearing that was scheduled for tomorrow.
Update 11/12/19: Appeal of Resolution 19-54 filed with DSI – Zoning Appeals office to be heard by City Council. This 91 page document presents further evidence of the danger of this development, pointing out errors in requirements, fact, procedure, and finding on 7 of the eleven findings of the Planning Commission that were used to support approval of this site plan.
Update 11/1/19: Our appeal was denied and the 2495 Kasota site plan approved with additional (inadequate) conditions in 7-7 vote broken by the Planning Commission Chair. SAPCC will appeal to the City Council.
UPDATE 10/28/19: At its meeting October 24, the Zoning Committee of the Saint Paul Planning Commission ended with a tied 3–3 vote on a motion to overturn the conditional approval of the site plan for 2495 Kasota Avenue, which Rohn Industries would like to turn into a parking lot for 25 semi trailers. The St. Anthony Park Community Council wants the approval
overturned because the ground contains contaminated materials of the old Elm Street Ash Dump.
The 3–3 tie vote means the site plan will go to the full Planning Commission without a recommendation from the Zoning Committee. READ MORE.
St. Anthony Park Community Council has many serious concerns about the potential air/waterborne pollutants that could manifest at the Rohn Industries 2495 Kasota Ave. project because an old ash dump underlies this site. We are also concerned with the traffic congestion this project would add to our neighborhood and the safety issues it would cause.
City staff have ignored SAPCC and the neighborhood’s concerns related to safety as well as our site-specific technical knowledge and history about this complex site in the review process, granting Conditional Approval 9/16/19. SAPCC filed an appeal of the conditional approval on September 25, 2019.
UPDATE 10/2/19: The planned public hearing date for the Site Plan with the Zoning Committee of the Planning Commission is October 24, 2019 followed by a Planning Commission vote on November 1, 2019.
Planning Commission decisions are appealable to the City Council. The City’s present deadline to act on the site plan review application is October 8, 2019. Because this deadline is prior to the November 1, 2019 Planning Commission meeting, the City elects to extend the deadline for the additional 60 days allowed under Minnesota Statute 15.99. The additional 60-day period takes effect immediately upon the expiration of the initial 60-day period.
Therefore, the deadline to make a final decision on the application is December 7, 2019.
Location of the Project
The half-mile area along Energy Park Drive/Kasota Ave. from Highway 280 west to 26th Street in Minneapolis was turned into the Elm Street Ash Dump between the 1930s and 1960s. At least 20 feet of debris—medical waste, contaminants and power plant incinerator ash from the city of Minneapolis, Hennepin County Medical Center, and the U of M—was piled up over time.
When Highway 280 was built in the 1960s, this stuff was covered with 6–12” of topsoil to stabilize it. Then, 20 years ago, BP Amoco wanted to build a gas station at 2495 Kasota Ave., and soil borings revealed a long list of buried hazardous materials, including lead, cadmium, barium, and mercury. The project was stopped after the St. Anthony Park Community Council and local residents objected and forced a special City Council hearing.
Currently, a local company, Rohn Industries, wants to develop a semi-trailer parking facility on this same site at 2495 Kasota Avenue between Highway 280 and the railroad crossing near the NAPA Parts driveway. This will require excavation and the addition of several feet of ballast to support the weight of the semis and trailers on the driveways and parking pads.
SAPCC is very concerned this work will expose the polluted material in the ground to our air and water. Airborne toxics could reach into North and South SAP, and possibly Prospect Park and Southeast Como in Minneapolis.
The four Kasota Ponds that surround the site are a known resting point for migrating waterfowl on the Mississippi Flyway. The ponds host fish, aquatic vegetation, fairy shrimp, and three species of turtles. The smallest pond is on the southwest corner of the proposed site and has high diversity of aquatic insects. These ponds will clearly be threatened if the site is developed.
For over 25 years, our local community has invested in protecting and improving the Kasota Ponds ecosystem. SAPCC has received multiple grants from the DNR and Mississippi Watershed Management Organization for cleanups, buckthorn removal, habitat restoration, and wildlife inventories. Hundreds of local residents have volunteered at these events.
Any tax revenue the city would gain by approving this development is not worth the potential for other costs. Cleanups of contaminated sites frequently run into the millions, if not tens of millions, of dollars, not to mention the potential health costs borne by the public.
At a minimum, the site should remain undisturbed.
Ideally, it should be remediated (the removal of all contaminated materials) and restored to its original wetland condition.
If you feel that approving the Rohn project is the proverbially “penny-wise and pound-foolish” situation, please add your name and contact information to the petition found on the Change.org website: http://chng.it/LbC2wBBr
SAPCC Actions Taken Thus Far
August 26, 2019 – Letter sent requesting more time to review site plan. View File
August 31, 2019 – Letter sent outlining concerns and urging project be tabled, a community engagement process be initiated, and public hearing be held. View File
September 5, 2019 – Letter sent further detailing concerns, requesting wetland delineation and wetland alteration documentation, and a traffic study be conducted. View File
September 25, 2019 – Appeal filed with Planning Commission. View File
Related documents and letters from other agencies: View Files
November 12, 2019 – Appeal filed with DSI for City Council. View File